Cittānupassanā – Contemplation of Mind: The Third Foundation of Mindfulness

Cittānupassanā – Contemplation of Mind: The Third Foundation of Mindfulness in Theravāda

Among the four foundations of mindfulness (Satipaṭṭhāna), Cittānupassanā (contemplation of mind) is the third — standing between Vedanānupassanā (contemplation of feeling) and Dhammānupassanā (contemplation of dhammas). If contemplating the body helps the meditator see physical nature clearly, and contemplating feeling reveals the raw affective tone of experience, then contemplating the mind reveals consciousness itself at work — knowing the mind as it actually is, not as we think it is.

Cittānupassanā is especially important because the mind is the “commander” of every action. The Buddha taught in the Dhammapada: “Mind precedes all phenomena; mind is their chief; they are mind-made.” Without understanding the mind and recognizing it, every effort at practice lacks a foundation — like trying to repair a car without knowing how its engine works.

What Does the Satipaṭṭhāna Sutta Teach About Contemplation of Mind?

In the Satipaṭṭhāna Sutta (MN 10), the Blessed One instructs us to contemplate the mind by recognizing sixteen states of mind arranged in eight contrasting pairs:

(1) Mind with lust (sarāga citta) — one knows it as a mind with lust; mind without lust (vītarāga citta) — one knows it as a mind without lust.

(2) Mind with hatred (sadosa citta) — one knows it as a mind with hatred; mind without hatred (vītadosa citta) — one knows it as a mind without hatred.

(3) Mind with delusion (samoha citta) — one knows it as a mind with delusion; mind without delusion (vītamoha citta) — one knows it as a mind without delusion.

(4) Contracted mind (saṅkhitta citta) — one knows it as a contracted mind; distracted mind (vikkhitta citta) — one knows it as a distracted mind.

(5) Exalted mind (mahaggata citta) — one knows it as an exalted mind; unexalted mind (amahaggata citta) — one knows it as an unexalted mind.

(6) Surpassable mind (sa-uttara citta) — one knows it as a surpassable mind; unsurpassable mind (anuttara citta) — one knows it as an unsurpassable mind.

(7) Concentrated mind (samāhita citta) — one knows it as a concentrated mind; unconcentrated mind (asamāhita citta) — one knows it as an unconcentrated mind.

(8) Liberated mind (vimutta citta) — one knows it as a liberated mind; unliberated mind (avimutta citta) — one knows it as an unliberated mind.

Detailed Method of Practice

Step 1: Recognize the Present State of Mind

The most basic method is simply recognizing which state the mind is in at this very moment. No judging, no trying to change it, no analyzing causes — just knowing. “Ah, the mind has lust.” “Ah, the mind is distracted.” “Ah, the mind is concentrated.” This bare recognition is like a mirror — it reflects without adding or subtracting anything.

In the tradition of Mahāsi Sayadaw, meditators are taught to “note” mental states: “wanting, wanting” when lust is recognized; “angry, angry” when hatred is recognized; “sleepy, sleepy” when sloth is recognized. The noting method helps the mind step back from the state being observed — you are no longer “someone lusting” but become “the one who knows lust.”

Step 2: Recognize Change

As mindfulness develops, the meditator begins to see clearly that the mind changes continuously — lust appears and a moment later is gone; anger flares up and a moment later dissolves. No state of mind lasts forever. This insight directly sees the impermanence (anicca) of the mind — something theory speaks of, but which only direct experience truly makes convincing.

Step 3: See Non-Self

When observing long enough and sharply enough, the meditator realizes: there is no “one” controlling the mind. A mind of lust arises not because “I want to lust” but because there is an attractive object + attention + mental habit. A mind of hatred arises not because “I want to be angry” but because there is an unpleasant object + attention + mental habit. The mind is a natural process (dhammatā), not a product of will.

Analysis of the Eight Pairs of Mental States

The First Three Pairs: The Three Poisons (Lust – Hatred – Delusion)

The first three pairs concern the three unwholesome roots (akusala-mūla): greed (lobha), hatred (dosa), and delusion (moha). These are the three basic “poisons” that give rise to all suffering. In contemplating the mind, the meditator recognizes the presence or absence of each of these poisons.

An important point: recognizing “the mind has lust” is not meant to lead to self-blame or guilt. The Buddha did not teach “do not have lust” but rather “know that lust is present.” This recognition itself has transformative power — when you clearly see lust as a conditioned, impermanent, non-self phenomenon, its force naturally diminishes.

Pair 4: Contracted Mind – Distracted Mind

This pair relates to two important hindrances: sloth and torpor (thīna-middha) and restlessness (uddhacca). The contracted mind (saṅkhitta) is a mind that has sunk down, lacking energy — drowsy and lazy. The distracted mind (vikkhitta) is a mind that jumps around, restless, thinking all over the place.

These two states are especially common in meditation and are a daily challenge for most practitioners. Recognizing them as soon as they appear is the first step in dealing with them — just as a doctor must diagnose the illness correctly before prescribing medicine.

Pairs 5–6: Exalted Mind – Surpassable/Unsurpassable Mind

According to the Commentary, the exalted mind (mahaggata) is the jhāna mind (meditative absorption) — of the fine-material or immaterial sphere. The unexalted mind is the ordinary sense-sphere mind. The surpassable mind (sa-uttara) is a mind that still has a higher mind above it; the unsurpassable mind (anuttara) is the highest mind the meditator has attained. These pairs help the meditator assess the degree of development of the meditative mind.

Pairs 7–8: Concentrated Mind – Liberated Mind

The concentrated mind (samāhita) is a mind that has reached access concentration or absorption concentration. According to the Commentary, the liberated mind (vimutta) has two meanings: temporary liberation (vikkhambhana-vimutti — defilements suppressed through jhāna) and permanent liberation (samuccheda-vimutti — defilements cut off through Path knowledge). Recognizing these two states helps the meditator assess their progress toward liberation.

Cittānupassanā in Different Meditation Traditions

The Mahāsi Tradition

In the Mahāsi tradition, contemplation of mind is integrated into the overall noting method. Whenever any mental state becomes prominent — lust, anger, boredom, joy — the meditator notes it as the primary object. “Wanting, wanting” when there is desire; “angry, angry” when there is hatred; “worrying, worrying” when there is anxiety. This method is particularly effective because it turns every mental state into a meditation object — no state is “bad” or “something to get rid of.”

The Ajahn Chah Tradition

The meditation master Ajahn Chah often taught contemplation of mind with a vivid image: “See the mind as someone sitting at home, and mental states as visitors. Visitors come and go — you don’t need to chase after them, nor do you need to drive them away. Just know that a visitor has come.” This approach emphasizes letting go and acceptance — the core attitude of Cittānupassanā.

The Pa-Auk Tradition

In the Pa-Auk tradition, contemplation of mind is practiced systematically according to the Abhidhamma. After developing jhāna and discerning mentality-materiality, the meditator contemplates each type of consciousness arising at each sense door — identifying which of the 89 types of consciousness it belongs to, which mental factors accompany it, and what conditions give rise to it. This approach is more detailed but also requires a firmer theoretical foundation.

Application in Daily Life

Contemplation of mind is not only for sitting meditation. In daily life, you can practice by pausing from time to time and asking: “What state is the mind in?” While working — is the mind focused or distracted? While talking — is the mind friendly or averse? While eating — is the mind greedy or calm?

This practice develops metacognition (awareness of one’s own cognition) — the ability to know clearly how one’s own mind is operating. In modern psychology, metacognition is regarded as a key factor for mental health, emotional regulation, and learning effectiveness. Theravāda Buddhism developed this system more than 2,500 years ago.

Conclusion

Cittānupassanā — contemplation of mind — is the art of knowing one’s own mind honestly, without judgment, and continuously. It helps us see that the mind is not “self” but a continuous stream of conditioned states — lust comes and goes, hatred comes and goes, concentration comes and goes. This understanding, when fully developed through vipassanā meditation, leads to liberation from identification with the mind — and that is an essential step on the path to realizing Nibbāna.

See also: SuttaCentral – Satipaṭṭhāna Sutta MN 10 | Access to Insight – Satipaṭṭhāna Sutta | Wikipedia – Satipaṭṭhāna Sutta

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Is contemplation of mind harder than contemplation of body and feeling?

Many meditation teachers consider contemplation of mind more subtle than contemplation of body, but not necessarily “harder” — it simply requires a different kind of mindfulness. Contemplation of body has concrete objects (the breath, postures); contemplation of feeling has clear objects (pain, pleasure). Contemplation of mind requires recognizing something more abstract — the “state” of the mind. With regular practice, however, this ability develops naturally. Many meditators find contemplation of mind the most fascinating because it opens up a rich inner world.

2. When contemplating the mind, I notice I have a great many unwholesome states. Is that a problem?

It is completely normal and even a good sign. Before practicing contemplation of mind, unwholesome states were still present, but you did not recognize them. Now you recognize them — that is progress, not regression. It is like shining a lamp into a dark room: you see the dust not because the room has become dirtier but because there is light. The Buddha did not teach “do not have unwholesome states” but “know when unwholesome states are present” — and this recognition is itself wholesome.

3. Can contemplation of mind be practiced without sitting meditation?

Absolutely — and in fact it should be. Contemplation of mind is especially suited to practice in daily life because you always have a mind! While waiting for the bus, sitting in a meeting, or cooking — at any moment you can pause for a second and recognize: “What state is the mind in?” This practice requires no special posture or quiet space — that is its greatest advantage.

4. How does contemplation of mind relate to mindfulness in psychotherapy?

Very closely. Mindfulness-based therapy programs such as MBSR (Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction) and MBCT (Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy) all use the principle of contemplating the mind — recognizing thoughts and emotions as temporary phenomena rather than identifying with them. The concept of “defusion” in ACT (Acceptance and Commitment Therapy) is very close to Theravāda contemplation of mind. The ultimate aims differ, however: psychotherapy aims at mental health, whereas Cittānupassanā aims at complete liberation.

5. Why did the Buddha list eight pairs rather than more or fewer?

The eight pairs cover the main aspects of the mind: the first three pairs (lust–hatred–delusion) concern the basic defilements; the middle two pairs concern mental energy (contracted/distracted and the degree of development); the last three pairs concern the qualities of meditative concentration (exalted/surpassable, concentrated, liberated). It is a system detailed enough to practice effectively yet simple enough to remember and apply. The Abhidhamma analyzes the mind into 89 types, but for the purposes of meditation practice, 16 states are just right.