DN 2: Sāmaññaphala Sutta — The Fruits of the Contemplative Life

The Discourse on the Fruits of the Contemplative Life (Sāmaññaphala Sutta, DN 2) is the second discourse of the Long Discourses (Dīgha Nikāya). It records the historic dialogue between King Ajātasattu and the Buddha Gotama about the practical benefits of the renunciant life that can be seen here and now, in this very life. It is one of the clearest and most complete presentations of the training in Virtue — Concentration — Wisdom in the entire Pāli Canon.

Historical Background of the Sāmaññaphala Sutta

King Ajātasattu — The One Who Asked About the Dhamma

Ajātasattu was the king who ruled Magadha, one of the sixteen great states (mahājanapada) of the Buddha’s time. He came to the throne after killing his father — King Bimbisāra, a devoted Buddhist and the first king to take refuge in the Triple Gem. This act of parricide left Ajātasattu burdened with heavy remorse, and it was that very torment that led him to visit the Buddha.

Before meeting the Buddha, Ajātasattu had gone in turn to the six most famous non-Buddhist teachers of the day and asked each the same question: “Is there any practical fruit of the contemplative life that can be seen here and now, in this very life?” — but none of them gave him a satisfying answer.

The Setting: The Full-Moon Night of Komudī

The meeting took place on the full-moon night of the month of Kattika (the tenth lunar month), also called the Komudī moon — when the white water lilies are in full bloom. Encouraged by the royal physician Jīvaka Komārabhacca, Ajātasattu led his retinue to Jīvaka’s mango grove, where the Buddha was staying with 1,250 bhikkhus.

A striking detail in the discourse describes the extraordinary silence of the Saṅgha, which so astonished Ajātasattu that he exclaimed: “May my son, Prince Udāyibhadda, enjoy such peace as this!” — words that reveal the anxious state of mind of a king living in fear.

The Six Rival Teachers and Their Views

Before hearing the Buddha’s teaching, Ajātasattu recounts the answers of the six rival teachers (cha tirthika) — the six greatest thinkers of the time. This is an extremely valuable historical document, because it records the schools of ancient Indian philosophy in the words of Buddhism’s own rivals.

1. Pūraṇa Kassapa — The Doctrine of Non-Action (Akiriya-vāda)

Pūraṇa Kassapa held that actions have no moral consequences. Whether one kills, steals or does good, no kamma is created. This is the doctrine of akiriya-vāda (non-action) — denying moral causality and thereby rendering all effort in practice meaningless. The Buddha regarded this as one of the most dangerous wrong views (micchā-diṭṭhi).

2. Makkhali Gosāla — The Doctrine of Fatalism (Niyativāda)

Makkhali Gosāla, leader of the Ājīvika sect, believed that everything is governed by fate (niyati). Beings pass through the round of rebirth (saṃsāra) like a ball of thread unwinding by itself — no one can do anything to change it. After a fixed number of lives, everyone is automatically liberated. The Buddha considered Makkhali the one who did the most harm to beings, because he completely denied personal effort.

3. Ajita Kesakambalī — The Doctrine of Materialism (Ucchedavāda)

Ajita Kesakambalī was a thoroughgoing materialist. He held that a human being consists only of the four elements (earth, water, fire, air); death is the end, there is no afterlife and no fruit of kamma. Giving is merely the “empty talk” of fools. This is the doctrine of ucchedavāda (annihilationism) — a complete denial of rebirth and kamma.

4. Pakudha Kaccāyana — The Doctrine of Eternal Elements

Pakudha Kaccāyana taught seven unchanging elements: earth, water, fire, air, pleasure, pain and the soul (jīva). These elements are created by no one, do not interact and do not change. When a sword cuts off a head, it merely passes through the space between the seven elements — no one kills anyone, and no one is killed.

5. Nigaṇṭha Nāṭaputta — The Doctrine of the Fourfold Restraint

Nigaṇṭha Nāṭaputta (Mahāvīra, founder of Jainism) taught that the Nigaṇṭha ascetic is restrained by a fourfold restraint (cātuyāma-saṃvara): restrained regarding water, restrained from all evil, washed clean of all evil, and suffused with the avoidance of evil. When Ajātasattu asked about the fruits of the contemplative life, Nāṭaputta spoke about discipline instead — failing to answer the question.

6. Sañjaya Belaṭṭhiputta — The Doctrine of Skepticism (Amarāvikkhepavāda)

Sañjaya Belaṭṭhiputta, the former teacher of Sāriputta and Moggallāna, was an “eel-wriggler” (amarāvikkhepa) — he neither affirmed nor denied anything. When asked whether there is an afterlife, he replied: “I do not say it is so, I do not say it is not so, I do not say it both is and is not so, nor do I say it neither is nor is not so.” This is a form of radical skepticism.

Ajātasattu reported that none of the six had answered his question. All six had gone off the point — like being asked about mangoes and answering about jackfruit.

The Buddha’s Answer — The Fruits of the Contemplative Life

Fruits Visible in This Very Life (Diṭṭhadhammika)

The Buddha began with the simplest fruits that anyone can see: a slave or a farmer who goes forth is honored, supported with offerings and protected by kings and ministers. This is a practical fruit of the contemplative life, visible right in the present — there is no need to wait for a future life.

But the Buddha did not stop there. He led Ajātasattu through the entire system of training, from the lowest to the highest, showing that the contemplative life brings fruits far more sublime.

From Virtue (Sīla) to Guarding the Sense Doors

The system of virtue (sīla) in this discourse is presented in three levels:

  • The lesser virtue (cūḷasīla): Not killing, not taking what is not given, living the holy life, not lying, not speaking divisively, not speaking harshly, not engaging in idle chatter.
  • The middle virtue (majjhimasīla): Not damaging seeds, not eating at the wrong time, not watching shows of song and dance, not wearing ornaments, not using high beds.
  • The great virtue (mahāsīla): Not practicing prophecy, physiognomy, fortune-telling, geomancy or astrology — all forms of wrong livelihood (micchā-ājīva).

After virtue, the bhikkhu practices indriya-saṃvara (restraint of the sense faculties) — when the eye sees a form or the ear hears a sound, he does not let craving or aversion invade. This is the step from outer virtue to inner virtue.

Mindfulness and Clear Comprehension (Sati-sampajañña)

The bhikkhu knows clearly what he is doing: when walking he knows he is walking, when standing he knows he is standing, when eating he knows he is eating. Sati (mindfulness) is continuous noting; sampajañña (clear comprehension) is clear understanding of the purpose and context of an action. These two qualities together form the foundation for concentration.

Abandoning the Five Hindrances (Pañca Nīvaraṇa)

The five obstacles to be overcome before attaining jhāna:

  1. Kāmacchanda (sensual desire) — like a debt that has been paid off
  2. Byāpāda (ill will) — like an illness that has been cured
  3. Thīna-middha (sloth and torpor) — like a prisoner set free
  4. Uddhacca-kukkucca (restlessness and remorse) — like a slave set free
  5. Vicikicchā (doubt) — like a traveler who crosses a desert and reaches safety

The Buddha uses wonderful similes to illustrate the joy of abandoning each hindrance — this is the most beautiful passage of the discourse, showing the relief and freedom that the practitioner feels.

The Four Jhānas (Cattāro Jhānā)

The First Jhāna (Paṭhama Jhāna) — The Simile of the Bath Attendant

Secluded from sensual pleasures, secluded from unwholesome states, the bhikkhu enters and dwells in the first jhāna — a state with vitakka (applied thought), vicāra (sustained thought), pīti (rapture) and sukha (happiness) born of seclusion.

“Just as a skilled bath attendant or his apprentice sprinkles bath powder into a bronze basin and kneads it again and again with water until it is evenly moistened — not too wet, not too dry, saturated inside and out.”

This simile illustrates how rapture and happiness pervade the whole body — there is no part of the body that rapture and happiness do not reach.

The Second Jhāna (Dutiya Jhāna) — The Simile of the Spring-Fed Lake

With the stilling of applied and sustained thought, he enters and dwells in the second jhāna — inner tranquility and unification of mind, with rapture and happiness born of concentration, without applied and sustained thought.

“Just as a deep lake with no inflow of water from the east, west, north or south, and no rain falling from the sky, yet cool water wells up from a spring at the bottom and pervades the entire lake.”

The rapture and happiness of the second jhāna are samādhi-ja (born of concentration) — arising from within, needing no external stimulus. It is a state that is self-sufficient and free.

The Third Jhāna (Tatiya Jhāna) — The Simile of the Lotuses

With the fading of rapture, dwelling in equanimity, mindful and clearly comprehending, experiencing happiness with the body, he enters and dwells in the third jhāna.

“Just as blue, red or white lotuses born in the water, growing in the water, rising up toward the surface, yet remaining immersed in the cool water — pervaded from root to tip.”

The Fourth Jhāna (Catuttha Jhāna) — The Simile of the White Cloth

With the abandoning of pleasure and pain, he enters and dwells in the fourth jhāna — neither painful nor pleasant, with purity of mindfulness due to equanimity (upekkhā-sati-pārisuddhi).

“Just as a man might sit covered from head to foot with a white cloth — so that there is no part of his body not covered by the white cloth.”

The fourth jhāna is the foundation for insight — the mind is completely pure, steady, unified and ready to be directed toward the knowledge and vision of liberation.

The Higher Knowledges (Abhiññā)

Insight Knowledge (Vipassanā Ñāṇa)

With a mind concentrated, unified and pure, the bhikkhu directs the mind to ñāṇa-dassana (knowledge and vision) — seeing clearly that this body is made of the four great elements, born of mother and father, sustained by food, impermanent, subject to breaking up and destruction. And consciousness (viññāṇa) — bound up with the body, yet not the body.

Psychic Powers (Iddhi-vidhā)

Having been one, he becomes many; having been many, he becomes one; he passes through walls, walks on water, flies through the air, touches the moon and the sun with his hand — this is the knowledge of psychic powers (iddhi-vidhā), the second fruit of the contemplative life.

The Divine Ear (Dibba-sota)

He hears the sounds of devas and humans, far and near, subtle and gross — the divine ear element (dibba-sota-dhātu).

Knowledge of Others’ Minds (Cetopariya-ñāṇa)

He knows clearly the minds of other beings: he knows a mind with greed as a mind with greed, a mind without greed as a mind without greed; a mind with hatred, a mind with delusion, a contracted mind, an expanded mind, a surpassable mind, an unsurpassable mind, a concentrated mind, a liberated mind — all these he knows clearly.

Recollection of Past Lives (Pubbenivāsānussati)

He recollects many past lives: one life, two lives, three lives… hundreds of thousands of lives — with name, clan, caste, food, lifespan, pleasure and pain. This is the knowledge of recollecting past lives (pubbenivāsānussati-ñāṇa), direct evidence of rebirth.

The Divine Eye (Dibba-cakkhu)

He sees beings passing away and being reborn according to their kamma: those who do good are reborn in happy realms, those who do evil are reborn in realms of misery. This is the knowledge of the passing away and rebirth of beings (cutūpapāta-ñāṇa), paired with the knowledge of past lives — one sees the past, the other sees the present.

The Destruction of the Taints (Āsavakkhaya) — The Supreme Fruit

This is the supreme fruit of the contemplative life — there is no fruit more sublime or more excellent. The bhikkhu knows as it really is: “This is suffering, this is the origin of suffering, this is the cessation of suffering, this is the path leading to the cessation of suffering. These are the taints, this is the origin of the taints, this is the cessation of the taints, this is the path leading to the cessation of the taints.”

With this knowledge, the mind is liberated from kāmāsava (the taint of sensual desire), bhavāsava (the taint of becoming) and avijjāsava (the taint of ignorance). He knows clearly: “Birth is destroyed, the holy life has been lived, what had to be done has been done, there is no more coming back to any state of being.”

King Ajātasattu Takes Refuge and Confesses

Having heard the teaching, King Ajātasattu was delighted and declared: “Venerable sir, I go for refuge to the Buddha, to the Dhamma and to the Saṅgha. May the Blessed One accept me as a lay follower who has gone for refuge from today until the end of my life.”

Then the king confessed: “Venerable sir, I have transgressed; foolish, deluded and unwholesome as I was, I killed my father, a righteous king, out of lust for power. May the Blessed One accept my confession.”

The Buddha accepted it, and after the king had left, he said to the bhikkhus: “If the king had not killed his father, then this very night, sitting in this very seat, the stainless and pure eye of Dhamma would have arisen in him.” — that is, he would have attained stream-entry (Sotāpanna). Even so, through taking refuge and confessing, King Ajātasattu still planted wholesome seeds for the future.

The Meaning of the Sāmaññaphala Sutta for Practitioners Today

The Sāmaññaphala Sutta is not only for monastics. It offers four great lessons for every practitioner:

First, it shows that practice has concrete, visible results — it is not something fanciful or vague. From the serenity of virtue to the rapture and happiness of concentration, each step brings practical fruit.

Second, the Virtue → Concentration → Wisdom system in this discourse is the clearest map of practice the Buddha ever presented. It shows that the path is not random but gradual and logical.

Third, the story of Ajātasattu reminds us that sincere confession is always accepted. Even after committing a grave offense, a mind turned toward the good can still create wholesome causes.

Fourth, the six rival teachers illustrate that not every spiritual path leads to liberation. Distinguishing right view (sammā-diṭṭhi) from wrong view (micchā-diṭṭhi) is the first step on the path of practice.

Glossary of Important Pāli Terms

Pāli termEnglish meaningExplanation
SāmaññaphalaFruit of the contemplative lifeThe benefits and results of the renunciant life of practice
JhānaMeditative absorptionA state of deep mental concentration, with 4 levels (fine-material sphere)
SīlaVirtueMoral rules, the foundation of practice
NīvaraṇaHindrance5 mental obstacles: desire, ill will, sloth, restlessness, doubt
AbhiññāHigher knowledge6 kinds of supernormal knowledge attained through concentration
ĀsavakkhayaDestruction of the taintsThe knowledge that completely eradicates the defilements — the supreme fruit
Micchā-diṭṭhiWrong viewMistaken views, especially those denying cause and effect
SotāpannaStream-entererThe first stage of noble ones, who has entered the stream of liberation
PītiRaptureJoyful delight and elation in meditation — a jhāna factor of the first and second jhānas
UpekkhāEquanimityA balanced, impartial state of mind — a jhāna factor of the fourth jhāna

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. Is the Sāmaññaphala Sutta only for monastics?
No. Although the discourse speaks of the fruits of the contemplative (renunciant) life, the system of Virtue–Concentration–Wisdom presented in it applies to lay followers as well. Lay people can keep precepts, practice meditation and develop wisdom — to a different degree, but by the same principles.
2. Did the six rival teachers really exist historically?
Yes. All six are historical figures confirmed by many sources, including the Jain scriptures. Nigaṇṭha Nāṭaputta is none other than Mahāvīra — the founder of Jainism, a religion that still exists today.
3. Did King Ajātasattu attain any noble fruit?
According to the discourse, Ajātasattu did not attain any noble fruit because of the kamma of killing his father. However, the Buddha said that without that kamma he would have attained stream-entry that very night. His sincere confession still helped him plant wholesome seeds for the future.
4. What is special about the four similes for jhāna?
The four similes (bath powder, lake, lotuses, white cloth) illustrate how rapture, happiness and stillness pervade the whole body at each level of jhāna. They show that jhāna is not an empty state but a full one — full of rapture, full of happiness, full of clarity.
5. Is it necessary to attain jhāna in order to be liberated?
This question has many viewpoints. The Mahāsi tradition holds that “access concentration” (upacāra-samādhi) is sufficient for Vipassanā. The Pa Auk tradition requires full jhāna. The Sāmaññaphala Sutta presents the path through jhāna, but this does not necessarily mean it is the only path.
6. Are psychic powers (iddhi) real? Why did the Buddha not encourage them?
According to the scriptures, psychic powers are real abilities attained through concentration. However, the Buddha did not encourage displaying them (DN 11) because: (1) they can be mistaken for magic, (2) they do not help onlookers abandon the defilements, (3) the supreme fruit is the destruction of the taints — liberating wisdom, not miraculous transformations.

Summary

The Sāmaññaphala Sutta (DN 2) is one of the most foundational discourses of Theravāda Buddhism, presenting the complete system of practice from virtue → concentration → wisdom → liberation. Through his dialogue with King Ajātasattu, the Buddha not only answered the question about the practical fruits of the renunciant life but also drew a complete map for every practitioner. At the same time, the discourse provides valuable historical material on six schools of ancient Indian philosophy, helping us understand the intellectual context in which Buddhism arose and developed.

Related Articles

<

p style=”font-size:14px;color:#999;margin-top:2em;”>Tags: digha-nikaya, tam-tang, tang-kinh, sa-mon-qua, jhana, gioi-luat, ajatasattu, ngoai-dao, thang-tri, abhinna

Leave a Comment