The 18 Early Buddhist Schools – Their Origins and Historical Significance
After the Buddha Gotama’s Parinibbāna, the early Saṅgha was united under a common system of doctrine and discipline. Over time, however, differences in the interpretation of the teaching, local customs and views on the Vinaya led to a division into many schools. Tradition records about 18 schools (or more), each contributing its own perspective to the treasury of Buddhist learning. Understanding the early schools helps us see clearly the roots of Theravāda and the place of this tradition in the history of Buddhism.
Historical Background: From Unity to Division
While the Buddha was alive, he was the point of reference for every dispute over doctrine and discipline. After his passing, the legacy of the Dhamma was preserved through the First Council at Rājagaha, presided over by the Elder Mahā Kassapa. There the Elder Ānanda recited the Sutta Piṭaka (the Basket of Discourses) and the Elder Upāli recited the Vinaya Piṭaka (the Basket of Discipline). This consensus, however, did not last forever.
About 100 years later, at the Second Council at Vesālī, a dispute broke out over the “Ten Points” (Dasa Vatthūni) – new practices of the Vajjiputtaka monks which the Elders considered violations of the Vinaya. These ten points included storing salt overnight, eating after the sun’s shadow had passed two finger-breadths beyond noon, drinking unfermented palm wine, and above all accepting gold and silver. The Council ruled that all ten were contrary to the Dhamma, but the group that disagreed broke away, creating the first major division in Buddhist history.
Two Main Branches: Sthaviravāda and Mahāsaṅghika
The most fundamental division was between the Sthaviravāda (the School of the Elders) and the Mahāsaṅghika (the Great Assembly). The Sthaviravāda, led by the Elders, held firmly to the Vinaya as it had been handed down. The Mahāsaṅghika, supported by the majority of monks, accepted more flexible adjustments. The differences were not limited to the Vinaya but gradually extended to doctrine: the Mahāsaṅghika tended to regard the Buddha as transcendent, whereas the Sthaviravāda held that the Buddha was a fully awakened being who nevertheless possessed a human body.
From these two main branches, many smaller schools continued to split off over time. According to Pāli, Sanskrit and Tibetan sources, the number 18 is given as a symbolic figure; in reality there may have been more or fewer depending on the method of classification.
The Schools Descended From the Sthaviravāda
Several important branches emerged from the Sthaviravāda. The Vibhajjavāda (the School of Analysis) is the branch that led directly to Theravāda, emphasizing the method of analyzing the teaching into its individual factors (vibhajja – analysis, distinction). The Sarvāstivāda (the “All Exists” School) held that dharmas truly exist in all three times – past, present and future – and developed the most voluminous Abhidharma literature. The Pudgalavāda (the Personalist School) proposed the concept of the pudgala (person) as an intermediate entity between self and non-self.
There were also the Dharmaguptaka, which greatly influenced Chinese Buddhism – its Four-Part Vinaya remains the principal monastic code used in East Asia to this day – as well as the Mahīśāsaka and the Kāśyapīya, which were also notable branches. Each school developed its own Abhidharma, reflecting its own way of systematizing the teaching.
The Schools Descended From the Mahāsaṅghika
The Mahāsaṅghika likewise divided into many branches. The Lokottaravāda (the Transcendentalist School) taught that the Buddha was wholly supramundane (lokottara), that his physical body was merely a manifestation, and that all his words belonged to ultimate truth. This view is regarded as a forerunner of the Mahāyāna idea of the Buddha’s Dharma-body. The Ekavyāvahārika held that all teachings share a single essence.
The Caitika and related branches such as the Aparaśaila and Uttaraśaila flourished in the region of Andhra Pradesh, India. They influenced the formation of the Prajñāpāramitā literature and early Mahāyāna thought. The Bahuśrutīya (the School of Great Learning) emphasized the importance of broad study of the scriptures. Although these schools no longer exist as independent institutions, they left a deep mark on the history of Buddhist thought.
The Role of Theravāda Among the Schools
Theravāda, according to its own tradition, is the direct continuation of the Vibhajjavāda – the branch supported by Emperor Asoka at the Third Council at Pāṭaliputta. At this Council, the Elder Moggaliputta Tissa compiled the Kathāvatthu (Points of Controversy), refuting the views of other schools and establishing the orthodox position of the Vibhajjavāda. Theravāda was then brought to Sri Lanka by the Elder Mahinda and developed into a distinct tradition.
What distinguishes Theravāda from the other schools is its complete preservation of the Tipiṭaka in the Pāli language – the only one of the early schools to have retained its entire canon. The other schools, though they had scriptures in Sanskrit or various Prakrits, survive only in part through Chinese and Tibetan translations. Theravāda’s Abhidhamma Piṭaka, consisting of 7 treatises, also differs significantly from the Abhidharma of the Sarvāstivāda (likewise 7 treatises, but with different contents).
The Relationship Between the Schools and Mahāyāna
A common misconception is that Mahāyāna arose directly from the Mahāsaṅghika. In reality the relationship is far more complex. Mahāyāna was not a separate school but a movement of thought and practice that arose from within the existing schools. Early Mahāyāna monks still lived in monasteries belonging to the early schools and followed the Vinaya of those schools.
According to the Buddhologist Étienne Lamotte, Mahāyāna thought had diverse origins, including influences from both the Mahāsaṅghika and the Sthaviravāda. For example, the concept of the Bodhisatta already appears in Theravāda’s Pāli literature (the Jātaka), but Mahāyāna developed it into its central ideal of practice. Modern research, particularly through resources on SuttaCentral and Access to Insight, makes it possible to compare the scriptures of the different traditions.
Legacy and Lessons for Practitioners Today
Of the 18 early schools, only Theravāda survives as a living tradition. The others gradually merged into Mahāyāna or disappeared with the decline of Indian Buddhism. Their legacy nevertheless lives on in the Chinese and Tibetan canons, in philosophical concepts, and in the rich diversity of Buddhist thought.
For Theravāda practitioners today, understanding the early schools helps us recognize that diversity of views existed very early in Buddhist history. What matters is not arguing over who is right and who is wrong, but recognizing that every tradition aims at the same goal: liberation from suffering and the realization of Nibbāna. An attitude of mutual respect and learning among traditions is the very spirit the Buddha taught.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Is the number of 18 schools accurate?
The number 18 is more symbolic than precise. Different sources (Pāli, Sanskrit, Tibetan, Chinese) give lists that do not fully coincide. Some sources record 20 schools or more. Nevertheless, the number 18 is the one most widely used in the tradition.
Is Theravāda the oldest school?
Theravāda regards itself as the oldest tradition, continuing directly from the original teaching through the Sthaviravāda and the Vibhajjavāda. Modern scholars, however, observe that all schools, including Theravāda, underwent development and additions over time compared with the Buddhism of the very beginning.
Do the schools other than Theravāda still have any influence?
Certainly. The Four-Part Vinaya of the Dharmaguptaka is still used in East Asia. The Abhidharma philosophy of the Sarvāstivāda profoundly influenced Tibetan Buddhism. The thought of the Mahāsaṅghika helped shape Mahāyāna. The legacy of the early schools lives on in contemporary Buddhism.
