Brahmavihāra – The Four Sublime States: Loving-Kindness, Compassion, Sympathetic Joy, Equanimity

Loving-kindness, compassion, sympathetic joy and equanimity — these four qualities of mind are not only a method of meditation but an entire art of living. To understand the Brahmavihāra rightly is to understand how the mind can become as vast as the sky, embracing all beings without distinction.

❧ ❧ ❧

Imagine a small candle lit in a dark room. Its light spreads out and reaches every hidden corner without asking whether that corner deserves to be lit, without distinguishing clean corners from dirty ones. This is the closest image for describing the Brahmavihāra — the four noble states of mind that the Buddha taught can be extended to all beings without limit.
Brahmavihāra (brahma = sublime, vihāra = abode, dwelling place), also called Appamaññā (the Immeasurables), comprises four qualities of mind: Mettā (loving-kindness — unconditional goodwill), Karuṇā (compassion — tenderness in the face of suffering), Muditā (sympathetic joy — gladness at the happiness of others) and Upekkhā (equanimity — clear-sighted balance amid all vicissitudes).
In the Theravāda tradition, the Four Sublime States are taught both as a meditation method capable of leading to jhāna and as a way of living. This is what makes the Brahmavihāra so special: it is at once a summit of meditation, a foundation of ethics, and a path leading to liberation.

What Is the Brahmavihāra? — Etymology and Meaning

The Pāli word Brahmavihāra is a compound of two words: brahma, meaning “sublime, divine, Brahmā-like”, and vihāra, meaning “dwelling, abode, way of living”. Taken together, Brahmavihāra can be rendered as “the abode of the sublime” or “the way of life of the Brahmās”.
Why “of the Brahmās”? In Buddhist cosmology, the Brahmā deities (Brahmā) are beings dwelling in the higher realms, completely free of sensual desire, living with a pure and expansive mind. When a practitioner cultivates and abides in these four states, their mind becomes like the mind of a Brahmā — vast, boundless, free of enmity.

Pāli

Brahmavihāra

A noble spiritual abode — where the mind dwells as a Brahmā does

Pāli

Appamaññā

The immeasurables — these four states are radiated immeasurably, without limit, to all beings

Sino-Vietnamese

Tứ Phạm Trú

The four abodes of the holy life — four dwellings of one who lives the noble holy life

English

Four Sublime States

Also “Four Divine Abodes” — four sublime states of mind, or four divine dwellings

The name Appamaññā (Immeasurable) emphasizes a core feature: these four states must be cultivated without any limit of scope. Not only sending loving-kindness to loved ones, not only feeling compassion for acquaintances — but extending it to all beings in every direction, without distinguishing near and far, friend and foe, human or animal, visible or invisible. It is precisely this boundlessness that gives the Four Sublime States their special transformative power.

Its Place in the Pāli Canon and Commentaries

The Brahmavihāra appears throughout the Pāli Sutta Piṭaka, from the Dīgha, Majjhima and Saṃyutta Nikāyas to the Aṅguttara and Khuddaka Nikāyas. Among these, the two most directly relevant discourses are the Karaṇīya Mettā Sutta (Discourse on Loving-Kindness — Snp 1.8) and the Mahāsaccaka Sutta (MN 36).

“Mātā yathā niyaṃ puttaṃ āyusā ekaputtamanurakkhe — evampi sabbabhūtesu mānasaṃ bhāvaye aparimāṇaṃ.” — Karaṇīya Mettā Sutta (Snp 1.8): “Just as a mother would protect her only child with her own life, even so let one cultivate a boundless mind towards all beings.”

In the Visuddhimagga — The Path of Purification, the Venerable Buddhaghosa devotes an entire long chapter (Chapter IX) to a detailed exposition of how to cultivate the Four Sublime States, including the definition of each state, its near and far enemies, the objects of practice, the method of breaking down the barriers (sīmā-sambheda), and the path to attaining the jhānas through these four states.
It is worth noting that the Brahmavihāra is not a purely Buddhist concept. According to scholars Richard Gombrich and Peter Harvey, the notion of brahma-vihāra already existed in Brahmanical thought before the Buddha’s time. What is remarkable is that the Buddha profoundly reinterpreted this concept: it is not merely a tool for gaining rebirth in the Brahmā world, but a means leading to awakening and complete liberation when combined with insight.

📚 A note on the scriptures In the Aṅguttara Nikāya (AN 4.125–128), the Buddha gives four separate discourses on Mettā, Karuṇā, Muditā and Upekkhā, describing in detail the benefits of each state when it is cultivated correctly and continuously.

Mettā — Loving-Kindness: Unconditional Goodwill

What is the nature of Mettā?

Mettā (or maitri in Sanskrit) is usually translated as “loving-kindness”, “goodwill” or “friendliness”. But not every kind of “love” is Mettā.
There are three kinds of “love” that need to be clearly distinguished:

  • Romantic love (pema): based on attraction, possessiveness and the wish to be loved in return. When it is not reciprocated, it easily turns into hatred.
  • Conditional affection: “I love you because you are good to me, because you are useful to me.”
  • True Mettā: a sincere wish for all beings to be well and happy — expecting nothing in return, without distinguishing near and far, not for personal gain.

The scriptures compare Mettā to a mother’s feeling for her only child — ready to give her life to protect the child. Yet Mettā is even wider: it is not reserved for a single person but is extended boundlessly to all beings.

A helpful comparison: Think of the sun. The sun does not choose to shine on good people and leave bad people in darkness. It shines equally on all — the rich, the poor, the virtuous, the wrongdoer, even grass, trees, earth and stones. That is the image of genuine Mettā: radiating without discrimination, without conditions.

The near enemy and far enemy of Mettā

The Theravāda tradition describes each sublime state as having two “enemies”:

  • The near enemy (āsanna-paccatthika) is a quality that resembles Mettā but actually corrupts it: clinging affection (pema). When we mistake possessive affection for Mettā, we suffer when the other person changes or leaves.
  • The far enemy (dūra-paccatthika) is its complete opposite: ill will and hatred (vera).

Step-by-step practice of Mettā

According to the Visuddhimagga and the tradition of Mettā meditation, the practitioner proceeds in the following sequence:

  1. Oneself: Begin with yourself. The phrase: “May I be well, free from suffering, healthy, and live happily.”
  2. A respected, beloved person: a teacher, someone worthy of veneration. Avoid starting with a romantic partner, as this is easily confused with pema.
  3. A dear friend: family, friends.
  4. A neutral person: someone neither dear nor hostile, a stranger.
  5. A difficult person, an enemy: this is the stage that truly tests the practitioner and brings the greatest progress.
  6. Breaking down the barriers (sīmā-sambheda): reaching a state of mind that no longer distinguishes among the four groups above — a mind equal towards all.
  7. Pervading the ten directions: radiating loving-kindness to all beings in every direction of the universe.

“Sabbe sattā averā hontu, abyāpajjhā hontu, anīghā hontu, sukhī attānaṃ pariharantu.” — The classic Mettā phrase: “May all beings be free from enmity, free from affliction, free from distress; may they live happily.”

According to the scriptures, Mettā can lead to the first three jhānas (first, second and third jhāna), but not to the fourth jhāna, because Mettā still contains the factor of sukha (pleasant feeling), which is incompatible with the complete neutrality of the fourth jhāna. This is an important point of difference from Upekkhā.
Modern psychological research has confirmed many benefits of loving-kindness (Mettā) meditation, including reduced anxiety, increased positive emotion, better-quality relationships and greater empathy — what the Buddhist scriptures described more than two thousand years ago.

Karuṇā — Compassion: Deep Empathy in the Face of Suffering

The nature of Karuṇā

If Mettā is the wish for beings to be happy, then Karuṇā is the wish for beings to be free from suffering. These two states complement each other like two sides of a coin — Mettā aims at bringing about good, Karuṇā aims at removing harm.
Etymologically, karuṇā is associated with the root kara (to do, to act) — it is not just a passive emotion but empathy that moves one to action. Karuṇā makes the heart tremble at the suffering of others (para-dukkhe sati sādhūnaṃ hadaya-kampanaṃ).

How is Karuṇā different from pity?

This is the most commonly misunderstood point. Pity (anukampā in the colloquial sense) often carries the implication of looking down from above — “I feel sorry for you because you are wretched, inferior to me.” That is not Karuṇā.
Genuine Karuṇā is empathy between equals — recognizing that all beings are capable of suffering, all wish to be free from suffering, and that this is a deep commonality between oneself and others. From this recognition, compassion arises naturally, without effort.

A real-life example: On seeing a homeless person lying on the pavement, pity might think: “How pitiful — lucky I’m not like that.” True Karuṇā thinks: “This person is truly suffering. They, too, wish to be free from suffering, just as I do. Is there anything I can do?” — and if nothing can be done, the heart still holds a kind wish for them.

The near enemy and far enemy of Karuṇā

  • The near enemy: Domanassa — grief, gloom. When witnessing suffering we cannot remedy, if we sink into despair and sorrow, Karuṇā has turned into an affliction. Genuine Karuṇā keeps its tenderness and empathy without being overwhelmed.
  • The far enemy: Vihiṃsā — cruelty, malice. This is the complete opposite of compassion.

Muditā — Sympathetic Joy: Gladness Without Envy

The nature of Muditā

Muditā is usually translated as “sympathetic joy” or “appreciative joy” — sincere gladness at the happiness and success of others. It is the third quality in the Four Sublime States and also the most difficult to cultivate of the four.
Why the most difficult? Because human beings naturally tend to compare themselves with others. When we see someone else promoted, wealthy or happy, a part of our mind often stirs with a slight discomfort — even if we do not want to admit it. That is envy (issā), the far enemy of Muditā.

A self-check question: When you hear that a friend has been promoted, what is your first reaction? “I’m truly happy for them!” — or is there a brief moment of something not quite glad before you feel happy? That brief moment is a sign of latent envy — and cultivating Muditā is the way to deal with it at the root.

Muditā is especially needed in the age of social media

Never has Muditā been as necessary as it is today. Social media constantly places us in a state of comparison: this person bought a house, that one went travelling, another succeeded in their career. The human brain already tends towards social comparison, and social media has amplified this tendency many times over.
Cultivating Muditā is not about pretending to be happy. It is a process of transformation from within: seeing the happiness of others not as a threat to oneself, but as something good in itself. Happiness is not a finite pie — someone else being happier does not mean that you are less happy.

The near enemy and far enemy of Muditā

  • The near enemy: Pahāsa — superficial excitement, outward merriment without depth. Smiling while still envious inside — that is counterfeit Muditā.
  • The far enemy: Issā — envy. One cannot truly rejoice in the happiness of others while envy rules the mind.

Upekkhā — Equanimity: Balance Grounded in Wisdom

The nature of Upekkhā

Upekkhā (equanimity) is the fourth quality and also the highest of the Four Sublime States. Yet it is also the most easily misunderstood, because outwardly it can look like indifference, coldness or apathy.
In the context of the Brahmavihāra, Upekkhā is defined as an even mind that leans to no side (tatramajjhattatā) — not swept into liking or disliking, not partial to friend or foe, not elated by pleasant things, not crushed by painful ones.

Why is Upekkhā not indifference?

This is an extremely important distinction. Indifference (adukkhamasukha-vedanā in a negative sense) arises from delusion and lack of care. The indifferent person does not see the suffering of others, or sees it but does not care because they are concerned only with themselves.
True Upekkhā arises from wisdom regarding kamma (kammassaka) — understanding that each being is the owner of their kamma and reaps what they have sown. From this understanding, the mind can remain balanced even when seeing others suffer or flourish — not because it does not care, but because it understands that some things lie beyond one’s ability to intervene.

“Upekkhā is a sturdy boat on a stormy sea — not that it does not feel the waves, but that it is not capsized by them.” — From commentary on the Visuddhimagga, Chapter IX

Why must Upekkhā be cultivated after the other three?

This is a subtle point in Theravāda teaching. If Upekkhā is cultivated from the outset, before the foundation of Mettā, Karuṇā and Muditā is in place, it can very easily become indifference. It is the other three states — especially Mettā — that open the heart, making it tender and caring towards beings. On that foundation, Upekkhā can arise as the equanimity of the wise, rather than the coldness of the unfeeling.

The near enemy and far enemy of Upekkhā

  • The near enemy: Aññāṇupekkhā — indifference born of delusion, failing to discern the suffering and happiness of others, not caring for lack of wisdom.
  • The far enemy: Rāga and Dosa — greed and hatred. When greed or hatred is present, the mind cannot be even.
🎯 A special point Of the four Brahmavihāras, only Upekkhā can reach the fourth jhāna — the highest of the fine-material jhānas in samatha. This is because the neutral, even nature of Upekkhā fully corresponds to the character of the fourth jhāna, where the mind no longer feels pleasure or pain but only pure clarity.

Summary Table: The Four Sublime States from Several Angles

The table below summarizes the main features of the four Brahmavihāras according to the Theravāda tradition:

StateDirected towardsNear enemyFar enemyJhāna attainable
Mettā (loving-kindness)The happiness of beingsPossessive affection (pema)Ill will (vera)First — third jhāna
Karuṇā (compassion)The suffering of beingsGrief (domanassa)Cruelty (vihiṃsā)First — third jhāna
Muditā (sympathetic joy)The joy of beingsSuperficial excitement (pahāsa)Envy (issā)First — third jhāna
Upekkhā (equanimity)Evenness towards all beingsIndifference born of delusion (aññāṇupekkhā)Greed and hatredFourth jhāna

The Brahmavihāra and Meditation (Samatha — Jhāna)

In the Theravāda system of meditation, the Brahmavihāra belongs to samatha meditation (tranquillity meditation) — the kind of meditation that develops concentration and calms the mind. It is among the 40 meditation subjects (kammaṭṭhāna) taught by the Buddha and the meditation masters.

Breaking down the barriers (Sīmā-sambheda)

The key point in cultivating the Brahmavihāra as samatha is reaching sīmā-sambheda — breaking down the barriers between the groups of persons. This is when the practitioner no longer distinguishes between:

  • Loved ones and strangers
  • Good people and bad people
  • Friends and enemies
  • Oneself and others

At this point the mind radiates loving-kindness (or compassion, sympathetic joy, equanimity) equally to all. This is a sign that absorption is near. If the practitioner notices that the mind still discriminates — still finds it easier to send Mettā to loved ones than to those they dislike — they need to continue practising until that barrier dissolves.

Mettā, Karuṇā, Muditā and the Third Jhāna

The first three states can lead to the first three jhānas because they still contain the factor of sukha (pleasure). Specifically:

  • First jhāna (paṭhamajjhāna): with applied thought (vitakka), sustained thought (vicāra), rapture (pīti), pleasure (sukha) and one-pointedness (ekaggatā).
  • Second jhāna: without applied and sustained thought; with rapture, pleasure and one-pointedness.
  • Third jhāna: without rapture; only subtle pleasure and one-pointedness.

The fourth jhāna cannot be reached with Mettā, Karuṇā or Muditā, because the fourth jhāna entirely abandons pleasure and pain (sukhassa ca pahānā dukkhassa ca pahānā), leaving only the pure clarity of Upekkhā and one-pointedness.

Upekkhā and the Fourth Jhāna

Upekkhā alone, being neutral by nature and free of the pleasure factor, can reach the fourth jhāna. This is the deepest of the four fine-material jhānas, characterized by complete purity, neutrality and one-pointedness. The fourth jhāna is an ideal foundation for subsequently developing vipassanā.

From the Brahmavihāra to Liberation

An important question is often raised: “Is cultivating the Brahmavihāra enough for liberation?” The Theravāda answer is very clear: not on its own, but it is an extremely important foundation.
The Brahmavihāra belongs to samatha (tranquillity meditation) — developing concentration, suppressing the hindrances (nīvaraṇa), and making the mind pure and strong. But according to Theravāda teaching, complete liberation requires insight-wisdom (paññā) — clearly seeing the impermanent, unsatisfactory and non-self nature of all phenomena. This can only be attained through Vipassanā meditation.
Nevertheless, the Brahmavihāra creates an ideal meditative foundation for Vipassanā. After emerging from a jhāna attained through the Brahmavihāra, the practitioner can immediately contemplate those very jhāna factors — recognizing their impermanence, unsatisfactoriness and non-self nature. This is a swift and effective path recommended by many Theravāda meditation masters.

💡 A view from the commentarial tradition The Venerable Nyanaponika Thera, in his classic work The Four Sublime States, pointed out: “The ultimate aim of attaining jhāna through the Brahmavihāra is to produce a state of mind that can serve as a firm basis for liberating insight — clearly seeing the true nature of all phenomena as impermanent, suffering and non-self.”

Interestingly, even the arahants and the Buddha himself often dwelt in the Brahmavihāra states. This shows that the Four Sublime States are not only a means to liberation but also an expression of the liberated mind. A liberated mind naturally abides in these four states.

Application in Modern Life

One of the things that makes the Brahmavihāra extraordinary is its universal applicability. You do not need to sit in meditation for hours to benefit from the Four Sublime States. These four states can be practised in all of our daily activities.

In the family

Mettā helps create a warm and safe family atmosphere — not possessive love, but sincere care for the growth and happiness of each member. Karuṇā helps us truly listen when loved ones share their difficulties — not rushing to offer solutions or judgement, but first understanding and empathizing. Muditā helps us genuinely rejoice in the success of our children or spouse, without a trace of comparison or expectation. Upekkhā helps us stay calm when the family faces trials — not indifferent, but a steady anchor that others can lean on.

At work and in society

In the workplace, Mettā becomes a leadership style that cares about employees’ well-being. Karuṇā helps managers understand the pressures and difficulties staff are facing instead of looking only at results. Muditā helps eliminate a culture of envy in a team — when one person succeeds, the whole team rejoices. Upekkhā helps us make fair decisions not driven by emotion.

Simple daily practice

The Venerable Nyanaponika Thera reminded us that the Brahmavihāra should not be just a “brief visit” but must become “the habitual abode of the mind”. Here are a few simple practices that do not take much time:

  • In the morning: Spend 5 minutes reciting the Mettā phrases for yourself before starting the day.
  • When walking down the street: When you see a stranger, silently think: “May they be well and happy.” That’s all.
  • Before a meeting or meeting a difficult person: Breathe deeply and send them Mettā — this is not weakness; this is strength.
  • When reading sad news: Instead of going numb or feeling bewildered, arouse Karuṇā for those who are suffering and Muditā for the relief efforts under way.
  • In the evening: Reflect on the day: were there moments when loving-kindness, compassion, sympathetic joy or equanimity were present? Where could I do better next time?

Those who wish to go deeper into the theoretical foundations of the Four Sublime States may also explore Ānāpānasati — Mindfulness of Breathing as a foundation of concentration before practising the Brahmavihāra intensively. The two methods complement each other very well: Ānāpānasati stabilizes the mind, the Brahmavihāra expands it.
To understand the relationship between the Brahmavihāra and the Five Hindrances (Pañca Nīvaraṇa) more deeply, it helps to know that Mettā is the direct antidote to the hindrance of ill will (vyāpāda-nīvaraṇa), Muditā counters sloth and torpor (thīna-middha), and Upekkhā counters restlessness (uddhacca). This is why, in meditative practice, understanding both systems together helps the practitioner adjust their practice more flexibly.
The whole Brahmavihāra system is presented thoroughly by BuddhaNet from the perspective of practical meditation, while the Karaṇīya Mettā Sutta on SuttaCentral provides the original text in many languages for reference and daily recitation.

❧ ❧ ❧

Frequently Asked Questions about the Brahmavihāra

How do Brahmavihāra and Appamaññā differ, or are they just two names for the same thing?

Basically, they are two names for the same group of four states (Mettā, Karuṇā, Muditā, Upekkhā), but each name emphasizes a different aspect. Brahmavihāra (Sublime Abode) emphasizes the noble, “Brahmā-like” quality — highlighting its sublimity. Appamaññā (the Immeasurables) emphasizes the unlimited scope — these four states must be radiated without boundary to all beings. The scriptures use both names depending on context, and students of the Dhamma should be familiar with both.

Can one cultivate the Brahmavihāra without sitting meditation? Can busy people practise it?

Absolutely. The Venerable Nyanaponika Thera, in The Four Sublime States, emphasized two levels of practice: formal meditation (sitting and radiating the states systematically) and practice in daily life (arousing loving-kindness when meeting strangers, compassion when seeing suffering, sympathetic joy when hearing good news, equanimity when facing injustice). Both levels are valuable and complement each other. For busy people, even 5–10 minutes of reciting the Mettā phrases each morning and maintaining awareness of the four states during the day is meaningful practice.

Sending loving-kindness to someone I dislike feels fake and uncomfortable. Is there anything that helps?

This is a common and completely normal experience. A few suggestions from the Mettā meditation tradition: First, remember that Mettā does not mean condoning that person’s bad behaviour — you simply wish them freedom from delusion, the cause of that behaviour. Second, instead of trying to like them, reflect: “They, too, want happiness and fear suffering, just like me.” Third, if it is still difficult, step back and radiate Mettā to a neutral person first. Do not force it — Mettā needs to be nurtured gradually, not coerced.

What is the difference between Upekkhā in the Four Sublime States and Upekkhā in the Seven Factors of Awakening (Bojjhaṅga) or the Fourth Jhāna?

This is a subtle question often asked in Buddhist study. The scriptures and commentaries distinguish many kinds of Upekkhā. Upekkhā in the Brahmavihāra is an even mind towards beings, partial to no one. Upekkhā in the Fourth Jhāna is a state of mind without pleasant or painful feeling, completely neutral in feeling. Upekkhā among the Seven Factors of Awakening is the balancing factor that keeps meditative energy from being too tense (excessive effort) or too slack. What they share is “not leaning to one side”, but each has its own meaning and function in its respective context.

What does modern science say about the benefits of loving-kindness (Mettā) meditation?

Modern scientific research has confirmed many benefits of Mettā meditation. Studies published in reputable journals (such as the 2008 study by Barbara Fredrickson and colleagues) show that Mettā meditation increases positive emotions, improves social connectedness, reduces symptoms of depression and anxiety, increases a sense of purpose in life, and even has a positive effect on the immune system. Interestingly, these scientific findings echo what the Buddha taught more than 2,500 years ago about “the eleven benefits of cultivating loving-kindness” recorded in the Aṅguttara Nikāya.

Why is Muditā considered the hardest of the Four Sublime States to cultivate?

Because Muditā requires us to overcome one of the deepest psychological tendencies: social comparison. According to the scholar Edward Conze: “In the depths of the mind, human beings often tend not to want to see the happiness of others.” Mettā is easier because we can wish others happiness without feeling threatened. Karuṇā is easier because pitying those who suffer does not affect our ego. But rejoicing in the success of others — especially when that person has what we ourselves want — demands that we truly go beyond the ego and comparison. Precisely because of this challenge, meditation masters regard Muditā as the subtlest quality of mind and the one most worth cultivating.