MN 27 – The Shorter Discourse on the Simile of the Elephant’s Footprint (Cūḷahatthipadopamasutta)

The 27th post in the Blog series for students of the Majjhima Nikāya, following the order MN 1 → MN 152.

1. Introduction

We meet someone for the first time. They speak with restraint, never compete to win, and answer whatever is asked of them concisely. After just one meeting, a conclusion has already formed in our mind: this is a trustworthy person. That conclusion arrives very quickly, and most of the time we never check it again.

MN 27 begins exactly at that point. A wanderer recounts four things he observed about the Buddha and declares that he has reached a conclusion. The Buddha hears the story retold and says something unexpected: such a simile is not yet complete.

2. Sutta profile

  • Number: MN 27
  • Pāli title: Cūḷahatthipadopamasutta
  • English title: The Shorter Discourse on the Simile of the Elephant’s Footprint (Vietnamese translation by Ven. Thích Minh Châu: Tiểu kinh Dụ dấu chân voi)
  • Vagga: Opammavagga – The Chapter on Similes (MN 21–30)
  • Paṇṇāsa: Mūlapaṇṇāsa (MN 1–50)
  • Location: Jetavana, Anāthapiṇḍika’s Park, Sāvatthī
  • Speaker: the Buddha (the opening is a conversation between the brahmin Jānussoṇi and the wanderer Pilotika, also called Vacchāyana)
  • Listener: the brahmin Jānussoṇi
  • Central theme: the distinction between inference from external signs and a conclusion based on one’s own direct realization; the entire path of sīla – samādhi – paññā is presented as tracking an elephant by its footprints.

3. Key passages

3.1. A large footprint and a hasty conclusion (mn27:3.2, 3.4)

“So passeyya nāgavane mahantaṁ hatthipadaṁ, dīghato ca āyataṁ, tiriyañca vitthataṁ. … ‘mahā vata bho nāgo’ti.”

Translation: “He would see in an elephant forest a large elephant footprint, long and broad. … (He would conclude:) ‘This must be a great bull elephant.’”

Context: these are the words of the wanderer Pilotika. He compares himself to a forest-goer who sees a large footprint and immediately draws a conclusion about the elephant. The four things he saw in the Buddha are: wise people of four classes – khattiyas, brahmins, householders, and ascetics – all prepare questions in advance to refute him, but when they meet him they cannot even ask them; instead they become his disciples.

3.2. The skilled tracker does not yet conclude (mn27:10.3, 10.6)

“Yo hoti kusalo nāgavaniko neva tāva niṭṭhaṁ gacchati: ‘mahā vata bho nāgo’ti. Taṁ kissa hetu? Santi hi, brāhmaṇa, nāgavane vāmanikā nāma hatthiniyo mahāpadā, tāsaṁ petaṁ padaṁ assāti.”

Translation: “A skilled elephant tracker does not yet come to the conclusion: ‘This must be a great bull elephant.’ Why is that? Because in an elephant forest there are dwarf she-elephants with large feet; this footprint might be one of theirs.”

Context: the Buddha retells the very same simile but carries it further. The skilled tracker keeps following: he sees a large footprint, then rubbing marks high up, then tusk scrapes and broken branches high up – and each time he still does not conclude. Only when he sees the elephant itself walking, standing, sitting, or lying down does he reach a conclusion.

3.3. When the simile becomes complete (mn27:26.5–26.7)

“Ettāvatā kho, brāhmaṇa, ariyasāvako niṭṭhaṁ gato hoti: ‘sammāsambuddho bhagavā, svākkhāto bhagavatā dhammo, suppaṭipanno bhagavato sāvakasaṅgho’ti. Ettāvatā kho, brāhmaṇa, hatthipadopamo vitthārena paripūro hotī”ti.

Translation: “It is at this point, brahmin, that a noble disciple has come to the conclusion: ‘The Blessed One is fully self-awakened, the Dhamma is well proclaimed by the Blessed One, the Saṅgha of the Blessed One’s disciples is practicing well.’ It is at this point, brahmin, that the simile of the elephant’s footprint has been completed in detail.”

Context: “this point” is when the mind has been liberated from the āsavas and one knows for oneself that one is liberated. Before that, even after attaining the four jhānas and the three true knowledges, the sutta still says the disciple has not yet finished concluding.

4. Core teachings

4.1. Pilotika’s four “footprints”: inference from the outside

Pilotika is not a shallow man. He observes systematically: the four most intelligent classes of society, the same approach (preparing questions to refute), the same result (unable to ask, then submitting). In scholarly terms, this is anumāna – inference from signs, a legitimate means of knowledge. In daily life, it is how we assess a doctor through the praise of former patients. It is useful, and it has limits. Application: recognize when you are inferring, instead of assuming you know.

4.2. The skilled tracker is one who knows how to defer judgment

The subtle point of the sutta: the Buddha does not reject the simile; he says it is not yet complete. The difference between an ordinary forest-goer and a skilled tracker does not lie in seeing more or less, but in knowing that a large footprint could also belong to a dwarf she-elephant. In daily life: a project with impressive reports is not necessarily a healthy project. In scholarly terms: this is where the Suttas distinguish ākāraparivitakka – reasoning based on appearances – from knowledge and vision of things as they really are. Application: when you find yourself about to say “it’s definitely…”, try asking “is there any other explanation?”.

4.3. The real footprints lie within the path of practice itself

Most of the sutta is a gradual description: a Tathāgata arises in the world and teaches the Dhamma; someone hears it, gains faith, and goes forth; keeps sīla, guards the sense faculties, has mindfulness and clear comprehension, lives content, seeks a secluded place, abandons the five hindrances, attains the four jhānas, and then the three true knowledges. At each step from the first jhāna onward, the sutta repeats a distinctive phrase (mn27:19.3): “Idampi vuccati, brāhmaṇa, tathāgatapadaṁ itipi” – “This too, brahmin, is called a footprint of the Tathāgata.” In other words, the footprints are not out on the road but within the practitioner’s own experience of practice. Application: a sitting session in which you are calm for five minutes is a footprint, not the destination.

4.4. “Coming to a conclusion” and “having concluded”

The sutta uses two very close expressions. At the point where the knowledge of the destruction of the āsavas has just arisen (mn27:25.5): the noble disciple has not yet finished concluding, but is coming to a conclusion. Only after the mind is truly liberated (mn27:26.5) is it “having concluded.” In daily life: it is like knowing how to swim – reading ten books is still different from floating on the water once. Application: do not rush to rank yourself, and do not be discouraged when you see that you are still on the way; the sutta describes the state of “on the way” as a real stage with real value.

5. Five Pāli words to learn

Pāli wordApproximate pronunciationEnglish meaningSignificance in the suttaMemory aid
hatthipadaHUT-thee-pa-daelephant’s footprintthe central image of the whole suttahatthi = elephant, pada = footprint
nāgavanikoNAA-ga-va-ni-koelephant tracker in the forestthe figure in the simile; there are clumsy ones and skilled onesnāga = bull elephant, vana = forest
niṭṭhaṁ gacchatiNIT-thang GUT-cha-ticomes to a definite conclusionrepeated like a drumbeat throughout the suttaniṭṭhā = the end point, the final mark
tathāgatapadata-THAA-ga-ta-pa-dafootprint of the Tathāgataa name for each stage of practice and realization, not for the destinationeach jhāna is a footprint along the path
āsavānaṁ khayaAA-sa-vaa-nang KHA-yathe destruction of the āsavas (taints)the point at which the elephant’s footprint simile becomes completeāsava = what oozes out; khaya = exhausted

6. A point easily misunderstood

Common misunderstanding: the sutta criticizes Pilotika’s faith as mistaken and teaches that only realization counts, while initial faith is worthless.

Why it is easily misunderstood: the phrase “the simile is not yet complete in detail” sounds like a rejection. Moreover, the structure of the sutta places Pilotika’s words at the beginning and then replaces them with the Buddha’s words, which can lead readers to think the first part is being negated.

A careful reading: the sutta does not say Pilotika is wrong; it says he has not gone all the way. The evidence is right in the text: immediately after Pilotika’s words, the brahmin Jānussoṇi gets down from his chariot and pays homage three times, and at the end of the sutta he himself goes for refuge (mn27:27.4–27.5) – faith arising from inference is still recognized by the sutta as a genuine step. What the sutta corrects is where one stops: taking external signs as the end point instead of the starting point. This is a reading based on the flow of the text; more detailed layers of interpretation belong to the Commentaries and are not discussed here.

7. Practice for the day

The “not yet concluding” exercise – 5 to 10 minutes.

  1. Sit still with your back straight and breathe naturally for about ten breaths, simply knowing the in-breath and out-breath.
  2. Recall a judgment that arose today about a person or a situation – the kind of sentence that begins with “they must be…” or “people like that always…”.
  3. Do not argue with that judgment. Just ask three questions: What did I actually see? From what I saw to the conclusion, how many extra steps did I take? Is there any other explanation?
  4. Observe the bodily sensations as you leave the conclusion temporarily suspended. There is often a slight discomfort, a tightness in the chest or shoulders. Note it arising, then note it easing.
  5. Finish with three breaths, without needing to settle anything.

This is an exercise in observing the mind; it is not intended as medical treatment and makes no promise of any spiritual attainment.

8. Three review questions

  1. What are the four “footprints” the wanderer Pilotika says he saw in the Buddha?
  2. Why does a skilled elephant tracker not jump to a conclusion on seeing a large footprint?
  3. According to the sutta, at what point has the noble disciple truly “come to the conclusion”?

9. One line to remember

A large footprint is not yet the elephant. When you see the track, keep walking; don’t sit down there and conclude.

10. References

  1. Pāli original (Mahāsaṅgīti Tipiṭaka): https://suttacentral.net/mn27/pli/ms
  2. English translation by Bhikkhu Sujato: https://suttacentral.net/mn27/en/sujato
  3. Vietnamese translation by Ven. Thích Minh Châu: https://www.budsas.org/uni/u-kinh-trungbo/trung27.htm
  4. Segment API (segment IDs) used for cross-referencing: https://suttacentral.net/api/bilarasuttas/mn27/sujato?lang=en

Answers to the review questions

  1. Wise people of four classes – khattiyas, brahmins, householders, and ascetics – all prepare questions in advance to refute him, but when they meet the Buddha they can no longer ask them and instead become his disciples; the ascetics in addition ask for ordination and later attain the final goal of the holy life (mn27:4.2–4.15; 7.11–7.19).
  2. Because in an elephant forest there are also she-elephants that are small but have large feet, so a large footprint is not enough to determine that it belongs to a bull elephant (mn27:10.3–10.6).
  3. When the disciple’s mind is liberated from the āsava of sensual desire, the āsava of existence, and the āsava of ignorance, and he knows for himself: “Birth is destroyed, the holy life has been lived…”; before that, even after attaining the four jhānas and the three true knowledges, the sutta only says he is coming to a conclusion (mn27:25.5; 26.1–26.6).

Next time: MN 28 – The Greater Discourse on the Simile of the Elephant’s Footprint (Mahāhatthipadopamasutta).