Devadatta – A Lesson on Schism in the Sangha

Devadatta – A Lesson on Schism in the Sangha in Buddhist History

Devadatta is one of the most controversial figures in Buddhist history – a cousin of the Buddha Gotama who renounced royal life to go forth, yet in the end became the one who split the Sangha (saṅghabheda), one of the five gravest offences (ānantariyakamma) in Buddhist teaching. Devadatta’s story resembles a classical Greek tragedy: a figure of noble birth and real talent, led to ruin by ambition for power and by envy – a timeless warning about the danger of an untamed ego, even within the monastic life.

The significance of Devadatta’s story reaches far beyond one man’s biography: it reflects one of the greatest challenges every religious community, organisation and society must face – division from within. An external enemy is easy to recognise and to unite against; the threat from within – from “our own people” – is what is truly dangerous and hard to deal with.

Background and Early Practice

Devadatta belonged to the Sakya clan. He was the son of King Suppabuddha and Queen Amitā – the Buddha’s paternal aunt. Devadatta was thus a cousin of Siddhattha Gotama, and the two grew up together in the palace at Kapilavatthu. When the Buddha returned to his homeland after his awakening, many Sakyan princes asked to go forth, among them Devadatta, Ānanda, Anuruddha, Bhagu, Kimbila and Bhaddiya.

In the early period Devadatta practised diligently and attained psychic powers (iddhi) through developing concentration – a considerable achievement that shows genuine spiritual ability. According to the Vinaya, however, Devadatta’s powers were of the “mundane” kind (lokiya iddhi), not “supramundane” (lokuttara) – that is, gained through the strength of meditative absorption but without insight into the nature of reality. This matters: Devadatta had power but lacked liberating wisdom, and power without wisdom to guide it is a formula for disaster.

The Plot to Seize Leadership of the Sangha

The turning point in Devadatta’s story came when he approached Prince Ajātasattu of the kingdom of Magadha. Devadatta used his psychic powers to impress the prince and build a relationship of power. With Ajātasattu’s backing, Devadatta went to the Buddha and demanded: “The Blessed One is now old and frail; please hand over leadership of the Sangha to me.”

The Buddha refused firmly: “Devadatta, I would not hand over the Sangha even to Sāriputta or Moggallāna, let alone to you – one to be spat out like spittle.” This refusal, though harsh, reflects a core principle: the Sangha is not the property of any individual, not even the Buddha – he is the Teacher, not the “owner” of the Sangha. The Buddha once said: “I do not lead the Sangha; I only point out the way.”

Rejected, Devadatta did not grieve and repent but nursed resentment and began plotting to harm the Buddha and to undermine the Sangha. This was the tragic turn: from a bhikkhu with the potential to become a noble one, Devadatta became the maker of the heaviest kamma.

Three Attempts on the Buddha’s Life

With Ajātasattu’s support, Devadatta tried three times to kill the Buddha, and failed each time. The first time he hired assassins to kill the Buddha, but when they came face to face with his majesty and compassion, the assassins submitted and became his disciples. The second time he rolled a great boulder down from Vulture’s Peak (Gijjhakūṭa) to crush the Buddha, but only a splinter of the rock struck him, drawing blood from the Buddha’s foot – this is the offence of “shedding the Buddha’s blood” (lohituppāda), one of the five ānantariyakamma.

The third time, Devadatta released the fierce elephant Nāḷāgiri (made drunk with liquor) to trample the Buddha on his almsround. Yet as the elephant charged, the Buddha radiated boundless loving-kindness (mettā), and the savage elephant suddenly stopped and knelt reverently at his feet. The scene shook the city of Rājagaha and cost Devadatta all his standing in the eyes of the lay followers.

Splitting the Sangha – The Gravest Offence

After his murderous plots failed, Devadatta turned to another tactic: splitting the Sangha (saṅghabheda). He proposed five additional rules that he claimed were “stricter”: (1) bhikkhus must live in the forest for life and not dwell in monasteries; (2) they must live on almsfood only and not accept invitations; (3) they must wear robes of rag-cloth only and not accept donated robes; (4) they must dwell at the foot of a tree and not under a roof; (5) they must be wholly vegetarian and not eat fish or meat.

The Buddha declined to make these five practices compulsory, declaring them optional (dhutaṅga – ascetic practices) rather than mandatory – an expression of the Middle Way between luxury and extreme asceticism. Devadatta exploited this refusal to slander the Buddha as “living in luxury” and persuaded 500 young bhikkhus (newly ordained, not yet experienced enough to discern right from wrong) to follow him, forming a breakaway group at Gayāsīsa.

The Buddha sent Sāriputta and Moggallāna to Gayāsīsa. The two elders taught the Dhamma to the 500 young bhikkhus, helped them see their mistake, and all of them returned to the Buddha. Devadatta, woken with this news, was so enraged that “hot blood gushed from his mouth” – a symbol of the self-destruction that hatred brings.

The Outcome and the Lesson of Kamma

According to the Theravāda tradition, Devadatta was finally swallowed by the earth (pathavī-vivara) – the ground opened and took him down to the Avīci hell, the place of the heaviest results. Yet the story does not end in despair: according to the Jātaka and the commentarial tradition, the Buddha foretold that after exhausting his kamma, Devadatta would be reborn and in the distant future would become a Paccekabuddha named Aṭṭhissara.

This detail is very important in Theravāda teaching: no being is condemned forever. Even Devadatta – who committed ānantariyakamma – will in the end be liberated. This is an expression of the boundless compassion of Buddhism: every being has the potential for awakening; only the time and effort required differ.

See SuttaCentral – Saṅghabhedakkhandhaka and Access to Insight – Cullavagga VII.

Lessons for Modern Life

Devadatta’s story offers many profound lessons for every organisation and individual. The first lesson: talent and power not guided by ethics become instruments of destruction. Devadatta had psychic powers, early prestige and the backing of political power – but he lacked a pure mind and liberating wisdom.

The second lesson: division from within is more dangerous than attack from outside. Devadatta was not an outside enemy – he was an insider who understood the structure and weaknesses of the Sangha, and precisely for that reason could do deeper harm. The third lesson: a critical and reforming spirit must spring from sincere goodwill, not from personal ambition. Devadatta’s five proposals looked “stricter” on the surface but were in fact tools for division, not for practice.

Learn more about the consequences of schism in the Second Council and DhammaTalks – Schism.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Did Devadatta really attain psychic powers? According to the Vinaya and the commentaries, yes. Devadatta attained mundane psychic powers through meditative concentration, but lost them all once strong unwholesome states arose in his mind.

Why did the Buddha not stop Devadatta from the start? According to the teaching on kamma, each being is responsible for their own actions. The Buddha admonished him many times but could not compel him, for free will is a fundamental principle in Buddhism.

Were Devadatta’s five proposals bad in themselves? Not necessarily. The five practices are legitimate ascetic practices (dhutaṅga), and many noble monks undertook them voluntarily. The problem was that Devadatta wanted to make them compulsory for everyone and used them as a pretext for division.

Why is splitting the Sangha the gravest offence? Because a harmonious Sangha is the foundation on which the True Dhamma endures and spreads. Destroying the Sangha means destroying the chance of liberation for countless beings in the future.